Ever found yourself staring at your garage, dreaming of the perfect adventure rig, and getting stuck on a truly weird comparison? You’re not alone. On one hand, you’ve got the brand-new, purpose-built Polaris Xpedition. On the other, the quirky, discontinued, but legendary Honda Element. It might sound like comparing a socket wrench to a sledgehammer, but we hear you.
You want a vehicle that can haul your gear, get you off the beaten path, and not let you down. The lines are blurring between street cars and off-road toys, and making the right choice for your money and your lifestyle is tougher than ever.
In this ultimate polaris xpedition vs honda element guide, we’re going to break down this unconventional matchup. We’ll dive deep into trail capability, daily drivability, long-term costs, and the nitty-gritty maintenance realities of both. By the end, you’ll know exactly which key to grab for your next adventure.
At a Glance: Defining Two Radically Different Adventure Machines
Before we pit them head-to-head, let’s get a clear picture of what we’re working with. These two vehicles come from completely different worlds, designed with wildly different priorities in mind. Understanding their core DNA is the first step in making the right choice.
The Polaris Xpedition ADV: The Purpose-Built Trail Dominator
Think of the Polaris Xpedition as the evolution of the Side-by-Side (UTV). It’s not just an open-air dune buggy; it’s a fully-enclosed “Adventure UTV” with features you’d expect in a modern truck. We’re talking a sealed cab, real heating and air conditioning, a full roof, and a dumping cargo box.
It’s designed from the ground up for one thing: dominating the trail. With its massive suspension travel, aggressive tires, and on-demand 4WD system, it’s built to crawl over rocks, blast through mud, and take you places a normal vehicle simply can’t go.
The Honda Element: The Quirky, Utilitarian Cult Classic
The Honda Element, produced from 2003 to 2011, is the Swiss Army knife of compact SUVs. It was built on a car platform (the CR-V) but designed for a life of utility. Its signature features are the waterproof urethane floor, clamshell side doors, and seats that can fold flat, fold up to the side, or be removed entirely.
It’s a beloved rig for campers, dog owners, and anyone who needs to haul bulky, dirty gear one day and drive to work the next. Its available RealTime 4WD makes it capable on dirt roads and in snowy conditions, but it is, at its heart, a street vehicle with a rugged attitude.
Off-Road Prowess: Where the Dirt Determines the Winner
This is where the differences become stark. If your adventures involve anything more than a graded fire road, one of these vehicles pulls ahead immediately. Let’s look at the hardware.
Ground Clearance, Suspension, and Articulation
The Polaris Xpedition is the undisputed champion here. It boasts up to 14 inches of ground clearance and FOX Podium QS3 shocks that provide long-travel suspension. This setup is designed to absorb huge bumps at speed and articulate over obstacles like logs and rocks, keeping all four tires in contact with the ground for maximum traction.
The Honda Element, even with its AWD option, sits much lower with around 6.9 inches of ground clearance. While you can install a lift kit and bigger tires, you’ll never achieve the suspension travel or raw capability of the Xpedition. Pushing an Element too hard on a technical trail risks expensive damage to the undercarriage and suspension components.
Drivetrain and Traction Systems
The Xpedition features a true, selectable 4WD system with a locking rear differential. This means you can force both rear wheels to turn at the same speed, which is a game-changer in low-traction situations like mud, deep sand, or rock crawling.
The Element’s RealTime 4WD is a reactive system. It primarily drives the front wheels and only sends power to the rear wheels after it detects front-wheel slippage. It’s great for slick roads but lacks the proactive control and brute force needed for serious off-roading.
The Trail-Legality Factor: A Critical Distinction
Here’s the single biggest practical difference: the Honda Element is street-legal everywhere. You can drive it to work, then head straight to the mountains. The Polaris Xpedition is an off-highway vehicle (OHV) and is not street-legal in most states. This means you’ll need a truck and a trailer to haul it to the trailhead, adding significant cost and complexity to every trip.
On the Pavement: Daily Driving and Road Trip Reality
An adventure rig often has to pull double duty as a commuter or a highway cruiser. In this arena, the roles are completely reversed.
Comfort, Safety, and Creature Comforts
The Honda Element is the clear winner for on-road life. It was designed to meet federal automotive safety standards, meaning it has airbags, crumple zones, and ABS brakes. It’s quieter, rides smoother, and is perfectly comfortable for long highway road trips.
While the Xpedition is praised for being “car-like” for a UTV, it’s still a UTV. It’s louder, the ride is stiffer on pavement, and it lacks the safety features of a passenger car. Driving it on the road (where legal) is a raw, visceral experience—fun for short trips, but fatiguing on a long haul.
Fuel Economy and Range
When considering a more eco-friendly polaris xpedition vs honda element choice, fuel consumption is a key factor. The Element, with its 2.4L K24 engine, typically gets around 20-22 MPG on the highway. With its 15.9-gallon fuel tank, you’re looking at a range of over 300 miles.
The Xpedition’s 999cc ProStar engine is powerful but thirsty, especially when working hard on the trail. Its 12.5-gallon tank means your off-road range is more limited, and you’ll likely need to carry extra fuel in RotoPaX or jerry cans for extended trips.
The Garage Test: A Polaris Xpedition vs Honda Element Guide to Maintenance and Costs
Your wallet is a huge part of the equation. Here’s a breakdown of what to expect from purchase price to long-term upkeep. This is where you’ll find our best polaris xpedition vs honda element care guide tips.
Upfront Purchase Price: New vs. Used
A new Polaris Xpedition starts around $30,000 and can easily climb over $40,000 with higher trim levels and accessories. It’s a major investment in a recreational vehicle.
A used Honda Element is a fraction of that cost. Depending on mileage and condition, you can find a solid example for anywhere between $5,000 and $15,000. This leaves a lot of room in the budget for maintenance, modifications, and gear.
Long-Term Maintenance and Common Problems
This section covers the most common problems with polaris xpedition vs honda element ownership. Both have their quirks.
- Polaris Xpedition: UTVs require more frequent maintenance. Expect regular checks of CVT drive belts, frequent oil changes (especially in dusty conditions), and cleaning air filters. Parts are specific to Polaris and can be more expensive.
- Honda Element: The K24 engine is legendary for reliability. However, they are known for oil consumption as they age. Other common issues include failing starter motors, worn suspension bushings, and leaks from the VTEC solenoid gasket. The good news? Parts are cheap and widely available, and it’s a very DIY-friendly vehicle.
Insurance and Registration
The Element requires standard, affordable automotive insurance and registration. The Xpedition needs a separate powersports insurance policy, which can be surprisingly costly, plus any state-required OHV registration fees and trail permits.
Practicality and Utility: Hauling Gear, People, and More
An adventure vehicle is all about hauling the right stuff to the right place. Here’s how they stack up in pure utility.
Interior Space and Versatility
The Honda Element is an absolute champion of interior versatility. You can remove the rear seats entirely to create a massive, flat, rubber-floored cargo bay perfect for hauling bikes, tools, or even setting up a sleeping platform for car camping. It’s a mobile base camp.
The Polaris Xpedition is more like a small truck. It has a separate rear cargo box with a payload capacity of around 600 lbs. It’s great for coolers, firewood, and dirty gear you want to keep out of the cab, but it lacks the Element’s cavernous and configurable interior space.
Towing and Payload Capacity
Both vehicles are surprisingly capable towers for their size. The Xpedition is rated to tow 2,000 lbs, perfect for a small utility or teardrop trailer. The Element is rated for 1,500 lbs, which is enough for a very light pop-up camper or gear trailer. Always check your owner’s manual and use proper equipment like a transmission cooler if you plan to tow regularly with an Element.
Frequently Asked Questions About Polaris Xpedition vs Honda Element
Can I make a Honda Element as capable as a Polaris Xpedition off-road?
No. You can improve an Element with a lift, all-terrain tires, and skid plates to make it a very capable “soft-roader” for forest service roads. However, you cannot replicate the Xpedition’s purpose-built suspension, low-range gearing, and locking differentials without astronomical cost and custom fabrication.
Is the Polaris Xpedition a good replacement for a car like the Element?
For most people, no. The lack of street-legality, highway safety features, and on-road comfort makes the Xpedition a dedicated recreational vehicle, not a daily driver. It’s a “second vehicle” for adventure, whereas the Element can be your only vehicle.
Which is a more sustainable or eco-friendly choice?
This is a tough one. The Element gets better fuel economy, but it’s an older vehicle. The most sustainable polaris xpedition vs honda element choice might be a well-maintained Element, as you’re keeping an existing vehicle on the road rather than consuming the resources to build a new one. However, modern engines like the Xpedition’s are often more efficient and produce fewer emissions for their power output.
What are the biggest benefits of a Polaris Xpedition vs a Honda Element for overlanding?
The biggest benefit of the Xpedition is its ability to access truly remote campsites that are unreachable by a vehicle like the Element. Its ruggedness inspires confidence on tough terrain. The Element’s biggest benefit is its self-contained nature; you can live and sleep in it, and you don’t need a second vehicle to get it to the trail.
The Final Verdict: How to Choose Your Adventure Partner
So, how do you make the final call in the polaris xpedition vs honda element debate? The best practice is to be brutally honest about your needs, budget, and where you actually go.
You should choose the Polaris Xpedition if:
- Your primary goal is extreme trail performance.
- You want to tackle rock crawling, deep mud, or technical mountain passes.
- You already own or are willing to buy a capable tow vehicle and trailer.
- Your budget allows for a $30,000+ specialized recreational vehicle.
You should choose the Honda Element if:
- You need one vehicle that can serve as a daily driver and a weekend camper.
- Your “off-roading” consists of dirt roads, festival campgrounds, and snowy commutes.
- You value interior versatility, DIY-friendly maintenance, and a lower purchase price.
- You want to drive your adventure rig to the adventure, not haul it there.
Ultimately, these two machines are fantastic at what they were designed to do. The Xpedition is a scalpel for dissecting tough trails, while the Element is a multi-tool for a life of varied adventures. Assess your reality, not just your aspirations, and you’ll make the right choice.
No matter which rig you end up with, the goal is the same. Get out there, get dirty, and make some memories. We’ll see you on the trail!
- 2018 Honda Accord Tire Size – The Ultimate Guide To Perfect Fit, - December 18, 2025
- 2012 Honda Accord Fuse Box Diagram – Your Ultimate Guide To DIY - December 18, 2025
- 2013 Honda Accord Fuse Box Diagram – Your Essential Guide To - December 18, 2025